The Doolan GroupLUXURY REAL ESTATE ADVISORS ← thedoolangroup.com
Home  ›  Neighborhood Guides  ›  Sunset Key
KEY WEST · PRIVATE ISLAND OFF KEY WEST

Sunset Key

Private island off Key West

A 27-acre private island - once Tank Island - sitting about 500 yards off Key West, reachable only by private ferry. A handful of island cottages and estate homes share white-sand beaches, tennis, and uninterrupted sunset views in total seclusion.

MARKET SNAPSHOT

Island residences to $7.95M asking (~$3,000/SF)

16 Sunset Key Dr listed $7.95M, Nov 2025; previously sold $4.3M in 2005. Resales are rare.

NOTABLE STREETS

Sunset Key Drive (private island; ferry departs near Mallory Square)

LANDMARKS

Sunset Key Cottages (Luxury Collection resort), private beach, island tennis and spa, ferry dock

THE LIFESTYLE

The ultimate Keys seclusion - arrive by boat, swim off a private beach, and watch the sunset with zero crowds, while Key West's restaurants are a ten-minute ferry ride away. Listings surface only every few years.

Thinking of buying or selling in Sunset Key?

Talk to someone who knows these streets. Call, text, or send a note — you’ll hear back from Brent directly.

Prefer the one-page version? Download the PDF guide

Brent M Doolan
The Doolan Group
LUXURY REAL ESTATE ADVISORS
Phone: 561-400-9276 · Email: thedoolangroup@gmail.com